sammys fish box

“From Fresh Catch to Breathtaking Views: A Review of Sammy’s Fish Box”


Sammy's Fish Box City Island New York City

If you’re looking for a seafood restaurant that’s been around for more than 50 years, Sammy’s Fish Box in City Island, New York City is the place to be. The restaurant has a rich history, having served countless visitors, locals, and tourists over the years.

Sammy’s Fish Box was founded in 1966 by Sammy “The Greek” Giatras, who ran the restaurant until his passing in 1999. Since then, his sons, Alex and Bobby, have taken over the restaurant’s management, keeping the restaurant’s rich heritage alive. Sammy’s Fish Box has been continually improving its menu, ambiance, and services over the years, establishing itself as a go-to seafood restaurant in New York City.

City Island, where Sammy’s Fish Box is located, is a quaint fishing village in the Bronx that feels like a small coastal town. The island has a rich history and is famous for its seafront restaurants, excellent seafood, and a vibrant maritime culture. Sammy’s Fish Box is the most popular restaurant on City Island and is a destination for seafood enthusiasts all over the world.

Sammy’s Fish Box offers a casual and relaxed atmosphere, where customers can walk in straight from the beach or the fishing boats. The restaurant is very family-friendly, with a menu that caters to all ages and tastes. Sammy’s Fish Box has an indoor dining area, an outdoor deck, and a tiki bar, where visitors can enjoy a cold beverage under the sun or the stars.

One of the things that make Sammy’s Fish Box unique is that they own their fishing boats. This ensures that the restaurant gets the freshest fish, clams, crabs, oysters, and lobsters that they serve every day. The restaurant also has a well-stocked bar, with a wide selection of local and international beers, wines, cocktails, and spirits.

Whether you’re in the mood for a simple grilled fish or a fancy seafood platter, Sammy’s Fish Box has it all. The restaurant is famous for its Fish Fry Fridays, a promotion where customers can enjoy a full plate of fried fish, fries, coleslaw, and tartar sauce for one low price. Sammy’s Fish Box also has a loyalty program, where frequent visitors can earn rewards and discounts on future visits.

If you’re a seafood lover and want to experience a traditional seafood restaurant that oozes character, history, and delicious food, Sammy’s Fish Box is the place to go. With its 50 years of experience, unparalleled quality, and friendly staff, Sammy’s Fish Box has become an institution in City Island and beyond.


Sammy's Fish Box History

Sammy’s Fish Box has been a staple in City Island’s seafood scene since it opened its doors in 1966. The restaurant was founded by Sammy Gugliotta and his wife, who had a passion for seafood and a dream of opening their own restaurant. They chose City Island as their location because of its rich history in the seafood industry.

Sammy’s Fish Box quickly gained popularity among locals and tourists alike. Its reputation for serving fresh, delicious seafood spread throughout the New York City area, and soon people were coming from all over to indulge in its famous clam chowder and lobster dinners.

The restaurant has been family-owned and operated since its inception, with Sammy’s children taking over the business in the 1990s. They have continued the tradition of serving high-quality seafood in a friendly, laid-back atmosphere, ensuring that Sammy’s Fish Box remains a favorite among locals and tourists.

Over the years, Sammy’s Fish Box has been featured in numerous publications and television shows, including The New York Times, Food Network, and Travel + Leisure. Its reputation as one of the best seafood restaurants in the country has only continued to grow with time.

As City Island has evolved over the years, so has Sammy’s Fish Box. In addition to the main restaurant, it now includes a seafood market and outdoor bar area, allowing guests to take home some of the freshest seafood around or enjoy a cocktail while overlooking the water.

Despite its success, Sammy’s Fish Box remains a family affair at heart. Sammy’s children and grandchildren continue to be involved in the day-to-day operations, ensuring that Sammy’s legacy of serving delicious, fresh seafood in a welcoming environment lives on.

Seafood Extravaganza

Seafood Extravaganza

Sammy’s Fish Box is all about seafood and we offer a wide range of options you can indulge yourself in. If you’re a seafood lover, you’re in for a treat! We have a mouth-watering selection of seafood dishes that are surely going to tantalize your taste buds. From our signature Lobster Bake to our array of crab dishes, Sammy’s Fish Box has it all.

Our menu features a selection of the freshest seafood including shrimp and a variety of fish dishes. Our dishes are prepared with the best ingredients, and you can taste the difference in every bite. Our expertly grilled shrimp and salmon dishes are crowd favorites, while our decadent crab cakes are perfect for those who want to try something new.

Our seafood extravaganza doesn’t stop there! We also offer Lobster Alfredo, a savory delight perfect for a fancy night out, and our Seafood Linguine, packed with shrimp and calamari. The combinations of seafood dishes we offer will definitely make your dining experience unforgettable.

We also cater to those who are not seafood inclined, our non-seafood options are also as scrumptious. Try our Angus Steak, crispy Chicken Wings and more.

Don’t forget to end your meal with one of our delectable desserts! Our New York Style Cheesecake and Chocolate Mousse Cake are a must try.

Come visit Sammy’s Fish Box, and experience the best seafood cuisine in town.


City Island

If you’re looking for fresh seafood and a charming nautical atmosphere, look no further than Sammy’s Fish Box on City Island. This family-owned restaurant has been a staple in the community since 1966, offering delicious seafood dishes and stunning waterfront views, all within driving distance from busy New York City.

City Island is a small, picturesque island in the Bronx, accessible via a bridge from the mainland. It’s known for its quaint, seaside vibes and historic homes, as well as its abundance of seafood restaurants. Sammy’s Fish Box stands out among its competitors, with its large, sprawling building and prime location on the water.

Upon arriving at Sammy’s Fish Box, you’ll notice the restaurant’s classic, nautical-inspired decor. The walls are adorned with vintage fishing gear, colorful buoys, and photos of City Island’s long, storied history. There’s a lively, bustling energy in the air, as families and couples make their way to their tables, ready to indulge in the freshest seafood around.

And speaking of the menu – it’s truly a seafood lover’s dream come true. Sammy’s Fish Box offers a wide variety of dishes, from classic New England-style clam chowder to hearty seafood platters overflowing with shrimp, scallops, lobster tails, and more. For those looking for lighter fare, there are plenty of salads and grilled fish options as well. And of course, no trip to Sammy’s would be complete without trying their famous fried seafood – the crispy, golden fried calamari and fish and chips are customer favorites.

But it’s not just the food that draws people to Sammy’s Fish Box – it’s the atmosphere as well. Whether you’re sitting outside on their spacious deck, taking in the stunning views of the Long Island Sound, or cozying up inside by the fireplace on a chilly evening, there’s a sense of warmth and comfort that envelops you at Sammy’s. It’s the perfect spot for a romantic date night, a family outing, or a casual get-together with friends.

Overall, Sammy’s Fish Box is a true gem in the heart of City Island. From the fresh seafood to the charming atmosphere, there’s something special about this restaurant that keeps people coming back time and time again. So if you’re looking for a taste of New England in the heart of New York, make a reservation at Sammy’s and see for yourself what all the fuss is about.


sammys fish box ambiance

Walking into Sammy’s Fish Box, you are immediately struck by the relaxed and casual atmosphere of the restaurant. The decor is themed around the sea, with a variety of nautical memorabilia adorning the walls.

As you make your way to your table, you’ll notice the dim lighting that gives the space a cozy and inviting feel. The muted colors and soft lighting create a warm and welcoming atmosphere that is perfect for a night out with friends or family.

The nautical theme is evident in every corner of the restaurant, from the fishing nets hanging from the ceiling to the vintage fishing rods and tackle on display. The decor transports you to a seaside fishing village, creating a unique and memorable dining experience.

The restaurant is spacious and comfortable, with ample seating options for both large and small groups. The tables are arranged to provide privacy and a sense of intimacy, while still allowing for easy conversation and interaction with your dining companions.

One of the highlights of the ambiance is the view of the water. Whether you opt to dine indoors or outside on the patio, you’ll enjoy a stunning vista of the ocean from your table. Watching the sun set over the water while enjoying a delicious meal is an unforgettable experience that truly adds to the relaxed vibe of Sammy’s Fish Box.

The overall ambiance of Sammy’s Fish Box is one of warmth, relaxation, and comfort. It’s the perfect place to unwind and enjoy a meal with friends, family, or a special someone.

Awards and recognitions

Awards and recognitions

Sammy’s Fish Box has been recognized for its excellence in seafood dishes for several years. Its dedication to providing customers with fresh, tasty, and high-quality seafood has earned it numerous awards and accolades. Some of these awards include:

  • The Certificate of Excellence from TripAdvisor
  • The Best Seafood Restaurant Award from the Bronx Times
  • The Best Seafood Restaurant Award from the Daily News
  • The Best Seafood Restaurant Award from the Bronx Chronicle
  • The Best Seafood Restaurant Award from the Bronx Times Reporter
  • Featured on the Food Network’s “Diners, Drive-Ins, and Dives.”

These awards and recognitions are a testament to Sammy’s commitment to delivering fresh, quality seafood to its customers. The restaurant has been in operation for over 50 years, and during this time, it has remained true to its roots by sourcing its seafood from local vendors and ensuring that it is always fresh.

Sammy’s has also been recognized for its commitment to community service and charitable causes. The restaurant has supported local organizations such as the Throggs Neck Girls Softball League and the Throggs Neck Benevolent Association. Additionally, the restaurant has donated food and money to organizations that support veterans and their families.

Despite its many awards and recognitions, Sammy’s has never lost sight of what makes it special – its dedication to providing customers with delicious seafood dishes in a warm and welcoming atmosphere. Whether you’re in the mood for a traditional fish and chips, a lobster roll, or a seafood tower, you can be sure that you’ll get the best seafood experience at Sammy’s.

The History and Legacy of Sammy’s Fish Box

Sammy's Fish Box

Sammy’s Fish Box is a legendary seafood restaurant that is located in City Island, New York. It was opened in 1966 by the late Sammy DeRose and it quickly became a beloved institution in the area. Sammy was a local legend, and he built his restaurant on the guiding principle that everyone should feel welcome and that they should be treated like family. His restaurant became a community hub where people would come together to celebrate special occasions or just to enjoy a delicious meal.

Over the years, Sammy’s Fish Box has become a treasured part of City Island’s history. Not only is it a staple of the local food scene, but it has also been featured in movies, TV shows, and even music videos. Sammy’s has hosted countless celebrities over the years, and it has become a destination for visitors from all over the world who are looking for a taste of authentic New York City seafood.

Sammy’s Fish Box has persevered through the years, largely due to its unwavering commitment to quality. The restaurant has never compromised on the freshness of its seafood, and it has always maintained the highest standards of cleanliness and hygiene. This dedication to quality has earned the restaurant a reputation as one of the best seafood spots in the city.

The Menu

Sammy's Fish Box Menu

Sammy’s Fish Box is known for its extensive menu of fresh seafood dishes. The restaurant serves everything from shrimp cocktails and clam chowder to live lobsters and fish and chips. The menu is designed to appeal to all tastes, with plenty of options for those who are looking for lighter fare as well as those who are looking for something more substantial.

One of the highlights of the menu is Sammy’s famous seafood platter, which is a generous serving of shrimp, mussels, clams, and lobsters served on a bed of ice. This dish is perfect for sharing with a group, and it is a great way to sample some of the restaurant’s most popular offerings. Other must-try dishes include the crab cakes, seafood bisque, and the lobster mac and cheese.

The restaurant also offers a range of non-seafood options, such as steak and chicken dishes, for those who prefer something different. And no meal at Sammy’s Fish Box is complete without trying one of their famous desserts, such as the apple pie or the chocolate lava cake.

The Ambiance

Sammy's Fish Box ambiance

The ambiance at Sammy’s Fish Box is warm, welcoming, and classic. The restaurant is furnished with dark wood paneling and comfortable seating, giving it a cozy and familiar feel. The walls are adorned with memorabilia from Sammy’s storied history, including vintage photos of the restaurant and the surrounding community. The overall effect is an ambiance that is both nostalgic and timeless.

In addition to the indoor dining area, Sammy’s Fish Box also has an outdoor patio that is perfect for al fresco dining during the summer months. The patio is set up with umbrellas and tables, so guests can enjoy their meals while taking in the fresh sea air and beautiful views of the water.

The Service

Sammy's Fish Box staff

The service at Sammy’s Fish Box is friendly, attentive, and professional. The waitstaff is knowledgeable about the menu and is always happy to make recommendations or answer any questions. They are also efficient and prompt in taking and fulfilling orders. The management and staff work hard to ensure that every guest has a memorable experience, and their dedication to customer satisfaction is evident in everything they do.

The Prices

Sammy's Fish Box prices

Despite its reputation for quality, Sammy’s Fish Box has managed to keep its prices affordable. The menu features a range of price points, from more budget-friendly options to more expensive items for special occasions. With generous portions and high-quality ingredients, the restaurant offers great value for the money. And, with regular specials and promotions, guests can enjoy their meals at Sammy’s Fish Box without breaking the bank.

The Location

Sammy's Fish Box location

Sammy’s Fish Box is located on City Island, a small community in the Bronx that is known for its seafood restaurants and picturesque views. The restaurant is situated right on the water, giving guests a front-row seat to the area’s natural beauty. It is easily accessible by car or public transportation, making it a popular destination for locals and visitors alike.

The Final Verdict

Sammy's Fish Box seafood

Sammy’s Fish Box is a true gem in the world of seafood restaurants. Its rich history, commitment to quality, and welcoming ambiance make it a must-visit destination for anyone who loves fresh seafood and classic dining experiences. Whether you are a local or a visitor to the area, a meal at Sammy’s Fish Box is sure to be a memorable one.

About admin